Frequently Asked Questions

How are the books chosen?

Each year Monica, Roxanne, and Jonathan start emailing each other in the fall with numerous versions of the list of contenders.  The first year, even before we made up our long list, we spent a lot of time considering criteria.  For example, how would a picture book fare against a YA novel?  Recognizing that there had to be some form of unity among the books on the roster we decided that the “fairest” thing was to select titles for a similar audience (middle grade, middle school, and high school readers). Once that was settled we spent many weeks working on a very long list that was winnowed down to the final 16 contenders in early December.

As to which titles finally are included each year – we won’t bore you with the details of the dozens of emails and negotiations between the three of us.  Suffice it to say that we look both objectively and subjectively, considering fan favorites, awards, stars, and our own critical views, keeping in mind that no matter which two books are paired together no single title can be an obvious winner.

Of course, as is inevitable when such a list is made, blood is shed; each of the three of us has had to leave behind favorites on this particular battlefield, but we always end up pleased with the range and diversity of the final list.

How do you decide on the brackets?

We determine the bracketing strategy (the books are matched up alphabetically by title) and then hand the list over to our colleagues at School Library Journal who recruit and assign the judges.

How are the judges selected?

Rick Margolis of School Library Journal works with publishers to bring in a diverse range of writers.  We are enormously appreciative of their willingness to judge this contest.

How did you come up with this idea anyway?

Once upon a time, a book lover (read: Monica) began following the Morning News’ Tournament of Books and dreaming of doing something similar with books for young people.  For that competition, the organizers  “… take 16 of the most celebrated and highly touted novels of the year…” and then pit them against each other in a March Madness-like contest.

Driving her friends, one especially (read: Roxanne), slightly crazy with her constant natterings, Monica finally found a way to make her dream a reality.  Another friend (read: Betsy Bird) suggested School Library Journal and not only were they interested, but incredibly enthusiastic about the idea.   Soon many people came on board and have now gone way beyond the call of duty to help with the project.

2009 was our first year and we were delighted with the success of the competition.  In 2010 we came here with a new arena and a new set of competitors, and judges.  We can’t wait for 2011!

Can we get an easy-to-read list of the 2010 contenders and judges?

Of course. Here you are:

The Contenders

Charles and Emma

Claudette Colvin

The Evolution of Calpurnia Tate

Fire

The Frog Scientist

The Last Olympian

Lips Touch: Three Times

The Lost Conspiracy

 Marcelo in the Real World

Marching for Freedom

Peace, Locomotion

A Season of Gifts

The Storm in the Barn

Sweethearts of Rhythm

Tales from Outer Suburbia

When You Reach Me

The Judges

M. T. Anderson

Christopher Paul Curtis

Nancy Farmer

Candace Fleming

Helen Frost

Shannon Hale

Angela Johnson

Cynthia Kadohata

 Julius Lester

Jim Murphy

Walter Dean Myers

Katherine Paterson

Gary Schmidt

Anita Silvey

Megan Whalen Turner

Who does the wonderful graphics?

The brilliant Mark Tuchman, creative director at School Library Journal.

Where’s the 2009 Battle?

It has been archived at our old site, but you can download the brackets and read all the matches here.

What does the winner get?

A virtual gold medal, of course.